Annual allowable cut report, a ‘what if’ scenario

MLA Simpson questions annual allowable cut predictions.

After the announcement the Gold Pan’s timber supply increased by 600,000 cubic metres, Cariboo North MLA Bob Simpson isn’t buying it – especially after reading the official report.

“This is just a modeling exercise,” Simpson said.

“It’s a what if scenario.”

In a release from the Ministry of Forests, Lands and Resource Operations, it states “a new silvicultural strategy analysis has been completed that identifies a 600,000 cubic metre increase in mid-term timber supply over previous projections in the Quesnel timber supply area.”

However, a document obtained by the Observer, the Draft Modelling and Analysis Report for Type III Silvaculture Strategy, cautions the “optimistic” findings.

“The new information used in this analysis has yet to be fully tested under sensitivity analyses and, as such, should be considered cautiously,” the report reads.

Cariboo North’s Independent MLA, says government’s optimistic spin boils  down to, “in an ideal world if we did X, Y and Z we think we might get this…”

“None of this is ground tested,” he said, adding the report mentions nothing of fire, climate change, pest, or disease.

The press release from the ministry states, “the main reasons for the higher mid-term forecast in this analysis, as compared to the previous mid-term analysis conducted in summer 2011, are due to the incorporation of new information that indicates lower pine mortality estimates in young stands, more live pine remaining in older stands and new managed stand site productivity estimates that these stands will grow faster than previously thought.”

Parliamentary Secretary for Forestry, John Rustad applauded the report and the findings.

“It’s great to see these initial results, which are encouraging for mid-term timber supply,” he said.

“These results also show the benefits of new digital and satellite technology.”

However the analysis obtained by the Observer, again cautions the optimistic findings.

“The shelf-life assumed in this analysis (20 years since time of impact) is considered somewhat optimistic and it is likely that some of the volume harvested in the model at the beginning of the second decade will be too degraded to process,” it reads.

“Failure to salvage significantly dead stands in favour of greener stands that would be viable even after dead volumes are past their shelf life will result in both lower midterm and long term harvest levels.”

Simpson said it’s situations such as this and the politicizing of issues that makes the public distrustful of the system.

“There’s no trust anymore,” he said.

“This report simply creates more timber by playing with the model.”


Just Posted

Four Rivers Co-op collecting donations for wildfire relief

The co-op is matching all donations they receive for the Red Cross

Traffic update: Charter bus stuck in flower bed by Carson Street gas station

Visibility is low for people driving through the City of Quesnel this afternon

75 active fires and 8 wildfires-of-note in Cariboo Fire Centre Aug. 17

The latest update on wildfires, evacuation alerts and orders in the Cariboo Fire Centre.

Editorial: When disaster strikes – the case for local news

In times of crisis, local news becomes more important than ever

North Baezaeko continues to grow; fire management team takes over

Narcosli Creek Fire still 70 per cent contained

PHOTOS: B.C. city wakes up to darkness under wildfire smoke

The rest of the province also dealing with thick haze as smoky skies continue

Safeway union urgest rejection of mediator recommendations

Says mediator asks for too many concessions

Fire chases B.C. crews out of their own camp

Crews in Burns Lake had to leave after a wildfire reportedly overtook their sleeping quarters

To address peacock problem, B.C. city moves ahead on trapping plan

Surrey’s new bylaw focuses on ensuring people no longer feed the birds, ahead of relocation

Hospitals to see ‘delays’ in care after losing Saudi students, health group says

About 1,000 Saudi residents called back to kingdom after suspending diplomatic relations with Canada

Bernier diatribe against ‘extreme multiculturalism’ boosts Liberal coffers

Party spokesperson Braeden Caley says online donations doubled, social media engagement quadrupled

‘Disjointed’ system hinders British Columbia First Nations in wildfire fight

More than 550 wildfires were burning in B.C. and crews were bracing for wind and dry lightning

Castlegar bridge designed by architect of collapsed Italian bridge

Riccardo Morandi designed the Kinnaird Bridge, which is part of Highway 3.

Federal government announces over $115 million to Royal Canadian Navy

Defence Minister Harjit S. Sajjan was at Victoria’s CFB Esquimalt to announce missile system upgrades

Most Read