Forestry Ink columnist Jim Hilton. (Photo submitted)

Forestry Ink: Are the Tarsands a blessing or a curse?

Columnist Jim Hilton looks at the pros and cons of oil sands mines

Jim Hilton

Observer Contributor

The recent announcement that Teck Resources Ltd. is pulling its application for a controversial new oil sands mine in Alberta started a flurry of accusations, with many seeing the issue as jobs versus climate. Beyond the climate change debate, the economics of the project have changed since it was first proposed in 2011, when crude prices often topped $100 a barrel and there were concerns that the world was running out of oil. Canada’s oil sands (in particular those of Alberta), which contain the world’s third-largest reserves, saw lots of spending as companies and countries rushed to secure supplies.

A major reason for the Teck withdraw is recent oil prices of $52 a barrel due in large part to fracking techniques used to unlock massive reserves in Texas’s Permian Basin. The mine was projected to produced about 260,000 barrels of crude a day but would also have emitted the equivalent of about 4.1 million tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) a year, making it difficult for Canada to meet its greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction targets.

A review of the pros and cons may help clarify the debate. As stated above, most of the pros deal with jobs and helping keep low oil prices. Even two of the pros may be of some concern, i.e. enormous growth potential (less than five per cent has been developed) and a 95-per-cent increase would mean an equivalent increase in some of the pollution concerns. The minimizing of GHG as being “potentially” doable is a concern when there are an estimated four million tons of CO2 produced a year. The other pros are ones we have heard of before, .i.e. large supply (third-largest in the world), which is economically recoverable at today’s oil prices.

The cons are numerous, with the oil sands already being Canada’s largest source of CO2 emissions. Typically, tar sands are strip-mined and the bitumen cooked out of two tons of sand for each barrel of oil, making the greenhouse gas and energy footprints of tar sands oil far larger than that of conventional oil. The amount of oil produced relative to the energy consumed is between 3:1 and 5:1, making tar sands an exceptionally high-cost and low-net-energy oil. Conventional oil was over 20:1.

Alberta, with only 10 per cent of the population, emits the most GHG emissions of any province. Provincial government has been slow to respond. Large amounts of water are required: roughly 3:1, which has resulted in water pollution, approximately three million gallons of toxic runoff per day, resulting in 50 square miles now covered in toxic pools. The mining is also destructive to major boreal forest, which is an important carbon sink, along with widespread habitat destruction, both on land and water. Ancestral lands have been destroyed, as well as an expensive and risky pipeline is needed to reach faraway markets. Even with the cancellation of the massive Teck project, existing production rates will replace many hectares of boreal forests with toxic ponds.

The Parkland Institute reported that the government has received less than 20 per cent of the wealth generated by oil sands production since 1997 even though its original target was 35 per cent. According to the report, Albertans have received an average of nine per cent since 1997.

Global News reported the Alberta government had been slow at producing an alarming climate report. The Ministry of Environment and Alberta Federation of Labour (AFOL) had requested the report produced months ago. Gill McGowan, president of the AFOL, said, “this approach could affect hundreds of thousands of people who could lose their jobs and their retirement savings. If they take money from the public sector, from the public purse, and use it to prop up oil and gas projects that have been rejected by global investors, that’s money that’s being taken away from education, health care, infrastructure, all those things that are already being underfunded. This is a recipe, from our perspective in the labour movement, for economic disaster.”

Jim Hilton is a professional agrologist and forester who has lived and worked in the Cariboo Chilcotin for the past 40 years. Now retired, Hilton still volunteers his skills with local community forests organizations.

READ MORE: Forestry Ink: How fast do wireless communications need to be?



editor@quesnelobserver.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

B.C. firefighters only responding to most life-threatening calls during COVID-19 pandemic

The directive comes after province spoke with paramedics, fire services, according to top doctor

Visitor to Kamloops army club tests positive for COVID-19: Interior Health

The individual visited Anavets 290 Army and Navy Club between March 13 and March 17

‘An extra $220 every 90 days’: B.C. patients pay more dispensing fees due to prescription limits

Kelowna woman says it’s outrageous to charge for refills every 30 days

A grateful community

Another community convoy to thank health care workers is planned for April 5

QUIZ: How much do you know about hockey?

Take this test and find out how well you know Canada’s most popular winter sport

QUIZ: How much do you know about hockey?

Take this test and find out how well you know Canada’s most popular winter sport

Researchers look at humidity as a weapon in the fight against airborne viruses

Regular hand washing, physical distancing and PPE for health care workers remains best line of defense

Two inmates found positive for COVID-19 at federal prison in B.C.; other tests pending

15 staff self-isolating waiting results, refusal to work notice sent, says correctional officer

Critic, workers’ group ‘disappointed’ Trudeau chose Amazon to distribute PPE

Amazon Canada said in an email to The Canadian Press that it is working with Canada Post, Purolator

How to cope with your mental health during a global pandemic

Becca Shears, clinical counsellor in Vanderhoof speaks about ways to deal with stress and anxiety during this time.

Full World COVID-19 update: National Guard collect ventilators in New York; Spain, Italy improve

Comprehensive coronavirus update with news from around the world.

Two people fined after B.C. police spot online ads re-selling 5,000 surgical, N95 masks

Police confiscated the masks, being sold at inflated prices, and now working with Fraser Health

Most Read