Is Canada really committed to coal phase out?

Canada needs ‘clean hands’ if it expects others to act on climate change

Just what is Canada’s position on coal?

Recently, Environment and Climate Change Minister Catherine McKenna was in London announcing an alliance with the United Kingdom that “will champion a global alliance on the transition from unabated coal-fired electricity at the United Nations climate change meetings in Bonn, Germany.

From cleaner air and public health to sustainability, the benefits of moving towards low or non-emitting sources of power are clear.

While she was there, the New York Times reported the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB) is trying to buy the coal assets of Rio Tinto – a deal estimated to be worth $2 billion.

The money for this deal was collected by the Canadian government from the paycheques of Canadians and their employers.

So what is Canada’s policy on coal?

Is it a phase-out or an investment opportunity?

Is the federal government committed to ridding the world of coal or just trying to drive down the value of coal assets so the CPPIB can scoop them up cheap?

Ms. McKenna is correct. Phasing out coal-fired electricity around the world will have a tremendously positive impact on climate, air pollution and public health. And, the technology is now available and economically viable.

Canada, however, derives only 10 per cent of Canada’s electricity of generated by burning coal. Ontario has already shut down its coal plants and most the other provinces have made commitments to do the same.

So, even though we are leaders in getting rid of coal, it has never been the huge challenge that many developed and developing countries face.

Leading a global alliance requires Canada to demonstrate a real commitment.

How can Canada be taken seriously if Canadian taxpayers’ pension payments are being used to make new investments in coal? At the very least, can’t our credibility be called into question?

The Rio Tinto deal isn’t unique. The CPPIB has holdings in at least 35 other coal companies, including Duke Energy, which was fined $100 million recently for polluting rivers in the United States with coal ash.

Isn’t this analogist to the old “Clean Hands” debate in the 1980s? How could we ask Ronald Reagan to clean up acid rain if Canada wasn’t willing to clean up its own act? Only after Ontario slapped regulations on INCO did the United States act. We had clean hands.

The CPPIB was set up to earn returns for Canadian pensioners at arm’s length to the government. In 1999, it was freed to go global and seek opportunities around the world.

Going global may have allowed the CPPIB gain better returns, but whether intentionally or not, it also made it part of Canada’s foreign policy. Its actions have a bearing on the success Canada’s diplomatic objectives.

Its dirty coal holdings and ambitions are seen as Canada’s.

In areas other than climate change and health, the CPPIB has recognized this by publicly stating it will not invest in land mines and will respect human rights.

So why when it comes to climate change Canada’s signature on the Paris Agreement and its championing of a global coal phase-out of coal is the CPPIB trying to buy more coal assets?

How will Ms. McKenna explain the actions of the Canada Pension Plan at climate talks in Bonn next month where she will “champion” a coal phase-out?

More importantly, how can she expect others to act when we don’t have clean hands?

John Bennett is the Friends of the Earth Canada senior policy advisor on Canada’s coal.

Just Posted

Becoming a Big Sister with BBBS Quesnel

An Observer reporter writes about her experience becoming a Big Sister through BBBS Quesnel

First Nations take steps to blockade moose hunt

Members of the Tsilhqot’in Nation are making good on their promise

Todd Doherty was recognized today for his life-saving actions during a flight home

Todd Doherty, Member of Parliament for Cariboo-Prince George, was recognized today for… Continue reading

Convicted animal abuser Catherine Adams faces breach of probation charge in Quesnel

Adams is scheduled to consult counsel in Quesnel Oct. 9, after breaching ban from owning animals

VIDEO: Messages of hope, encouragement line bars of B.C. bridge

WARNING: This story contains references to suicide and may not be appropriate for all audiences.

VIDEO: B.C. deer struggles with life-preserver caught in antlers

Campbell River resident captures entangled deer on camera

Scheer pushes Trudeau to re-start Energy East pipeline talks

Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer questioned the Prime Minister over Trans Mountain project

Mistaken identity: Missing dog claimed in Moose Jaw belongs to another family

Brennen Duncan was reunited with a white Kuvasz that was found in Saskatchewan

Abandoned kitten safe and sound thanks to B.C. homeless man

‘Jay’ found little black-and-white kitten in a carrier next to a dumpster by a Chilliwack pet store

Police chief defends controversial marijuana seizure

Advocates said cannabis was part of an opioid-substitution program in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside

Trans Mountain completes Burrard Inlet spill exercise

Training required, some work continues on pipeline expansion

Supporters of B.C. man accused of murdering Belgian tourist pack courtoom

Family and friends of Sean McKenzie, 27, filled the gallery for brief court appearance in Chilliwack

Pot, cash, mansions: Judge divvies up illegal estate of divorcing B.C. couple

The Smiths ran a multi-million marijuana operation that spanned three counties

Most Read